Rings of Power looks good but it s unlikely to win over Tolkien fans TechRadar Skip to main content TechRadar is supported by its audience. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Here's why you can trust us. Rings of Power looks good but it s unlikely to win over Tolkien fans By Matt Evans published 16 July 2022 Will Tolkien lovers be happy with the Amazon TV show? (Image credit: Amazon) The new trailer for Amazon's Lord Of The Rings: The Rings Of Power landed on July 14, and to be honest, it looked great. Showcasing more of the characters, designs, sets, sounds, and a real glimpse into the action of this new version of Middle-Earth, it looks like somebody spent around 500 million dollars bringing the Second Age of Middle-Earth to life. However, with Amazon's hoards of gold and the scope of talent involved, it was always going to look this good. The real question is whether it's possible to fill five planned seasons of TV, create a decent plot out of events spanning more than 3,000 years, and still honor the story created by J.R.R. Tolkien. Doing it all at the same time seems nigh-on impossible, but if we're lucky, we might get two out of three. Retelling old stories  It's not an enviable task. There's a lot going on in the Second Age of Middle-Earth, an era of uneasy peace that leads to the rise of LOTR's big bad Sauron. The drama plays out over thousands of years across locations familiar to those who have seen the older films, like Rivendell and Lothlorien, and unfamiliar ones like the island of Númenor. Old faces like Elrond, Galadriel, and Isildur are back, along with new ones like Gil-Galad the elvenking. The Second Age ends with the elves and men joining forces to fight Sauron, which we last saw twenty years ago in the opening minutes of Fellowship Of The Ring. In order to squish things down into something resembling a plot, lead writers J. D. Payne and Patrick McKay have taken the broad strokes of Tolkien's notes and used them to engineer a story that spans the entirety of Middle-Earth. They've condensed the timelines so that everything happens more or less at once, and invented new characters out of whole cloth to try and stitch everything together. The Harfoots, one of three types of proto-Hobbit, are barely mentioned outside of the Fellowship Of The Ring (the book), in a long-winded "Concerning Hobbits" prologue. But Amazon's new show has placed the Harfoots center-stage, designing costumes and culture and turning them into characters that will be heavily involved in driving some of the plot along. It's the equivalent of turning Luke Skywalker's throwaway line in A New Hope-"You fought in the Clone Wars?"-into hundreds of hours of prequel content. Other characters who were previously just named parts of a family tree, like dwarf-king Durin IV, are now flesh-and-blood people with goals and roles to play in the action. An all-new elf-human couple has also been invented, presumably to retread that Arwen-Aragorn forbidden love story. (Image credit: Amazon) Creating new stories There's a lot of new stuff here, and tinkering with Tolkien's legendarium has garnered the showrunners a lot of criticism from dedicated LOTR geeks. But people criticizing the changes have to remember that when Peter Jackson and co. were creating the LOTR movies in the nineties, big changes had to be made to create those adaptations, too. Aragorn had to be given a character arc. Arwen's role was beefed up to add more women into the mix. Many minor characters had to be cut, and even here, timelines had to be condensed. When Gandalf runs away to research Bilbo's ring, in the books he's actually gone for 17 years. Time's been very kind to almost all the changes Jackson made on those films, and they're now seen as the gold standard of fantasy on screen. However, Jackson then went and made the Hobbit movies, and that was the last time new characters and storylines were created to expand and pad out a Tolkien story. Initially billed as two films, it was expanded into a trilogy to challenge the box office domination of the Avengers and Hunger Games franchises. The results were... mixed, to put it politely. The Hobbit trilogy didn't need to be as long as it was, and while the male-dominated story needed a few new characters like elven archer Tauriel-there's not a single named woman in the book version of The Hobbit-turning the Battle Of The Five Armies, which lasts just two pages in the book, into its own three-hour film seemed excessive and soulless. But hey, money talks. (Image credit: Amazon) Missing the point This is a story that's going to be incredibly difficult-maybe impossible-to tell well on film. The amount of changes and finagling that have to be made by the writers to make sure it's coherent enough to adapt is a clear indication that it was never meant to be told this way. Maybe it should have stayed on the page. We all know why this is getting made, and it's not out of some deep respect for Tolkien or a burning desire to see Númenor onscreen; the bottom line is that Amazon spent a lot of money on this IP, and it's going to make them even more. It's quite sad that the key message of The Hobbit, that hoarded dragon-gold isn't as valuable as food, cheer and song, feels a little corrupted in the hands of the biggest corporation in the world. The Rings Of Power, on a macro level, is a blockbuster ploy to keep our money and attention on Prime Video and away from Netflix and Disney Plus. It's this sort of cynicism that is the absolute antithesis of Tolkien's work, and in order to win over book fans like me, being a good fantasy show on its own merit is simply not going to be enough. It has to be truly great to justify its own existence, otherwise, Tolkien lovers are going to write it off as just another Wheel Of Time. Matt EvansFitness & Wellbeing EditorWith a Master's Degree in journalism from Cardiff University, Matt started his digital journalism career at Men's Health and stayed on for over two years, where he earned his stripes in health and fitness reporting. Since then, his byline has appeared in a wide variety of publications and sites including Runner's World, Women's Health, Men's Fitness, LiveScience and Fit&Well on everything from exercise, to nutrition, to mental health, alongside covering extreme sports for Red Bull. Stretching is Matt's top fitness tip. He originally discovered exercise through martial arts, holding a black belt in Karate, and trained for many years in kickboxing. During COVID he also fell in love with yoga, as it combined martial-arts style stretching with a bit of personal space. When he's not training or writing about health and fitness, he can be found reading doorstop-thick fantasy books with lots of fictional maps in them. TechRadar Newsletter Sign up to get breaking news, reviews, opinion, analysis and more, plus the hottest tech deals! Thank you for signing up to TechRadar. You will receive a verification email shortly. There was a problem. Please refresh the page and try again. MOST POPULARMOST SHARED1You may not have to sell a body part to afford the Nvidia RTX 4090 after all2The iPhone 14 Pro is made of the wrong stuff; the Pixel 7 proves that to me3Apple October launches: the new devices we might see this month4Google's AI editing tricks are making Photoshop irrelevant for most people5Blizzard made me explain Overwatch 2 smurfing to my mum for nothing1Best laptops for designers and coders 2The iPhone 14 Pro is made of the wrong stuff; the Pixel 7 proves that to me3Stop saying Mario doesn't have an accent in The Super Mario Bros. Movie4iPhone 15 tipped to come with an upgraded 5G chip5Google Pixel Tablet is what Apple should've done ages ago Technology Magazines (opens in new tab)● (opens in new tab)The best tech tutorials and in-depth reviewsFrom$12.99 (opens in new tab)View Deal (opens in new tab)