Someone should make a game about: Set theory Eurogamer.net If you click on a link and make a purchase we may receive a small commission. Read our editorial policy. Someone should make a game about: Set theory Game, match. Feature by Chris Tapsell Reviews Editor Updated on 28 Oct 2019 29 comments Hello, and welcome to our new series which picks out interesting things that we'd love someone to make a game about. This isn't a chance for us to pretend we're game designers, more an opportunity to celebrate the range of subjects games can tackle and the sorts of things that seem filled with glorious gamey promise. Check out our 'Someone should make a game about' archive for all our pieces so far. Set theory is a mess. Or at least I think it's a mess. I skipped it, if I'm being honest, back when I was studying this sort of thing, because I'd heard it was very interesting but also a one-way ticket to a very bad grade. It really is interesting though. From what I gather, set theory grew out of one person, Georg Cantor, discovering in 1873 that there was a bit of a problem with maths. A problem which has remained "open" - unsolved by mathematicians or philosophers - to this day. The specifics are a bit out there, involving real numbers and irrational numbers and transcendental numbers - don't ask - but basically, he discovered that there can be two sizes of infinity. And that does not make sense. I love when things don't make sense. Games are very good at solving things, especially with their stories but also, just as especially, with their puzzles - but they are not very good at not making sense. Not yet. They rely on logic to such an extraordinary extent, from the logic of the code on which they're made to the logic of how you actually play them. You learn that doing A produces result B; you need to get B so you do A. Jump on the Goomba, rotate the tetromino, pull off the double jump. You learn the rules, you follow them, you progress. What I'd love is, from time to time, for that to be undermined; for the goalposts to be moved, the logic broken. Imagine having to adapt to a world that doesn't make sense, or work your way through it. There are glimpses of it in things I've played: What the Golf?, of all games, does this in a very literal sense, teaching you something then immediately throwing it back in your face (and making for some brilliant physical comedy at least, even if it doesn't quite capture what I mean). Destiny 2 did something that I'll remember forever where, at some point in a certain mission, you'll jump into a great abyss. For just a split second the world seems to blacken and morph. The dark rushes up to meet you but keeps on going over your head, and you seem to arrive on the floor beneath the floor, all inside-out and wrong side-up. Through the looking glass - then back to shooting things in the face. Games can do this at a proper scale, I think. They can play with physical space and passage of time in a way that little else can. Virtual space can make ants run along mobius strips, and send you through time, and cram great expansive mazes into miniature buildings. Games can cheat, in other words, and put things on screen that can't work in your mind. Back to set theory, for just a minute, and you'll see what I mean. Think about Russell's Paradox: a set of things that aren't in sets. Either the set contains things that aren't in sets, and therefore they also are in sets; or, the set doesn't contain things that aren't in sets, and therefore it's not a set of things that aren't in sets. Yuck. But set theorists disagree! They didn't solve that paradox - because by definition paradoxes are unsolvable - so much as they sort of stepped around it. Set theorists "axiomised" set theory - they created symbols for communicating the meanings of it, because symbols are capable of conveying much more specific, precise meanings than the words we use in everyday language - and once it was axiomised Russell's Paradox just wasn't really a problem. It's a curio, for sure, but one of "naive" set theory, as the egg-heads put it now. They cheated. And that's the joy of it. A lot of courses on a philosophy degree - like set theory, or so I hear from less tactically-minded coursemates - have you study a problem for ten weeks and at the end of it you realise the problem can't be solved. What someone's done is found a way to work around it, and I'd love the have the same sort of futility, the same mess of logic and illogic, thrown at me in a game. That way, like when struck with some paradox of philosophy, you couldn't use the old rules you've learned. You'd have to let the game cheat you, and you'd just have to move on. Become a Eurogamer subscriber and get your first month for £1 Get your first month for £1 (normally £3.99) when you buy a Standard Eurogamer subscription. Enjoy ad-free browsing, merch discounts, our monthly letter from the editor, and show your support with a supporter-exclusive comment flair! Support us View supporter archive More Features Digital Foundry Nvidia GeForce RTX 4090: a new level in graphics performance The Digital Foundry video review - and how the new GPU champion delivers for 4K 120fps gaming. 14 Feature Evercore Heroes wants to wind people up the right way "There's less rage at them, because they didn't end your fun." Feature What games get wrong about horses And what they could do about it. 34 Feature Shout out to all the Overwatch supports - where would we be without you? Merci. 55 Latest Articles Digital Foundry Sennheiser's legendary HD 599 open-back headphones are just £70 at Amazon in the Prime Early Access Sale Comfortable with neutral sound and a wide sound stage. Preview Football Manager's new Console edition is the best you'll get without a PC Getting Touch-right. 1 Splatoon 3 Amiibos will be out next month Ink-coming! 3 Fans think Phil Spencer's shelf is teasing the Xbox Game Pass streaming box UPDATE: Xbox confirms old Keystone prototype. 61 Supporters Only Premium only Off Topic: Take a minute to appreciate Cookin' with Coolio's incredible scallops recipe. What a great book. Premium only Off Topic: Reading City of Glass in comic form "Where exactly am I going?" Premium only Off Topic: Il Buco is a transporting film about a really big hole Underlands. Off-Topic Netflix handled Sandman brilliantly It was Dreamy. 9 Buy things with globes on them And other lovely Eurogamer merch in our official store! Explore our store