Tip The Real Science of Leg Extensions Search Skip to content Menu Menu follow us Store Articles Community Loyal-T Club Loyal-T Points Rewards Subscribe to Save Search Search The World s Trusted Source & Community for Elite Fitness Training Tip The Real Science of Leg Extensions Leg extensions are bad right Dangerous and useless Well not so fast Here' s the science by Nick Tumminello June 25, 2018July 8, 2022 Tags Bodybuilding, Legs, Tips, Training I recently I had the honor of co-authoring a peer-reviewed and highly-referenced paper for an NSCA journal with biomedical engineering PhD student, Andrew Vigotsky. It's titled, "Are The Seated Leg Extension, Leg Curl, And Adduction Machine Exercises Non-Functional Or Risky?" Many trainers and coaches argue that the knee extension places tensile forces on the anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) and patellofemoral joint (PFJ). They say these exercises can be considered dangerous and instead recommend exercises like squats. In our paper, we demonstrated how this perspective is not only shallow, but is also logically inconsistent. Here are some key points on leg extensions from our article: Indeed, tensile forces are placed on the ACL during the knee extension exercise. However, when examining these forces, remember that they exist on a continuum, and injury is not a concern until a certain threshold is reached. For the ACL, this threshold has been reported to be upwards of 2,000 N, depending on an individual's age. So the tensile forces experienced by the ACL during the knee extension (158 – 396 N, using loads ranging from a dynamic 12 repetition-maximum to a maximum voluntary isometric effort) are less than one-fifth of its ultimate strength. ACL forces during the knee extension are less than or equal to many other "functional" tasks, such as walking or landing. Therefore, knee extensions do not appear to be any more unsafe for the ACL than what's required for everyday activity. The recommendation of the squat being a safer exercise for knee ligament health is also logically inconsistent. For example, one study suggests that posterior cruciate ligament (PCL) forces in the squat are about an order of magnitude, or ten-times greater than those placed on the ACL during the knee extension. To put this in perspective, the PCL:ACL ultimate strength ratio does not approach such a difference (10:1) and is closer to 1.5 – 2:1. Thus, many of the arguments against utilizing the knee extension in healthy populations out of concern for ACL health are unfounded and logically inconsistent. When it comes to the PFJ, speaking about forces is not enough. Instead, consider the stresses, as the force is distributed over a given area of tissue. Indeed, such comparisons have been made, and they suggest that bodyweight squats to 90° knee flexion elicit greater peak PFJ stress than EMG amplitude-matched knee extensions, especially with greater knee flexion. Nevertheless, if working with symptomatic individuals, exercise selection and range of motion should be tailored to the individual as per the recommendation of a physical therapist or medical professional; otherwise, the knee extension, like the squat, should not be considered universally contraindicated. With that in mind, many trainers and coaches STILL think all you need are compound movements for a complete training program, and that seated or lying exercises designed to create a resistance challenge mostly on a single-joint action, such as many machine-based exercises, don't have a positive (functional) transfer into improving sports performance or reducing injury risk. Well, when it comes to strengthening the quads, there's a multitude of studies showing better strength gains in the quads (even among post ACL reconstruction patients) when combining open-kinetic chain exercises like leg extensions along with closed-kinetic chain exercises like squats and lunges over using only closed-kinetic chain exercises. Not to mention, the additional benefits of using single-joint exercises along with compound exercises has been highlighted in research on soccer players from two of the best premier-league division teams in Sweden. Researchers divided 30 players into two groups: one group received additional specific hamstring training using the lying leg curl machine, and the other group did the same strength and conditioning programs without the additional specific hamstring training using the lying leg curl machine. Results showed that the occurrence of hamstring strain injuries were clearly lower in the group (3 out of 15) that did additional specific hamstring training using the lying leg curl machine than in the control group (10 out of 15) that did not get the additional hamstring training. Additionally, compared to the group that wasn't prescribed lying leg curls, the group that received the addition of lying curl increased sprint speed. Cressey E. The Truth About Leg Extensions. T Nation, LLC. 2006. Vigotsky A et al. Are the Seated Leg Extension, Leg Curl, and Adduction Machine Exercises Non-Functional or Risky? NSCA Personal Training Quarterly 2017;4(4):50-53. Treubig D. Why You Should Be Using Knee Extensions After ACL Reconstruction. Modern Manual Therapy. 2018. Askling C et al. Hamstring injury occurrence in elite soccer players after preseason strength training with eccentric overload. Scand J Med Sci Sports. 2003 Aug;13(4):244-50. PubMed. Get The T Nation Newsletters Don' t Miss Out Expert Insights To Get Stronger, Gain Muscle Faster, And Take Your Lifting To The Next Level related posts Training Specialization A Serious Lifter s Secret Weapon Stuck in a rut? Dig yourself out with a specialization plan. Here's how to do it with any goal. Christian Thibaudeau July 26 Training Tip The Best Ab Exercise You re Doing Wrong Get your hip flexors out of this movement and you'll build better, stronger abs. Take a look. Abs, Bodybuilding, Tips, Training Pieter van der Linde December 31 Training How to Turn Up Your Gains Want to get bigger? Here's the smart lifter's guide to programming volume for all kinds of gains. Bodybuilding, Training Rudy Mawer August 11 Training Tip Go Hard Then Go Home But Go Hard Often How to adjust your training week to allow for more protein synthesis and trigger more muscle growth. Bodybuilding, Powerlifting & Strength, Tips, Training Dean Graddon June 20