Call of Duty: Vanguard - a tech marvel marred by bugs and stuttering issues Eurogamer.net If you click on a link and make a purchase we may receive a small commission. Read our editorial policy. Call of Duty: Vanguard - a tech marvel marred by bugs and stuttering issues The Infinity Ward engine evolves once again. Face-off by Thomas Morgan Senior Staff Writer, Digital Foundry Updated on 13 Nov 2021 27 comments The release of Call of Duty: Vanguard is a contentious one - but on a technological level, it's a return for the brilliant Modern Warware 2019 engine (known internally as IW8), enhanced and expanded upon to accommodate the ambitious of Sledgehammer Games' latest offering. There are engine advances designed specifically for multiplayer, but for my money, it's the campaign that is the star of the show. Telling the story of an elite squadron delivered via set-piece after set-piece, the technology shines thanks to brilliant materials work, stunning lighting and remarkable volumetrics. IW8 was always designed to scale across the generations - and the end result is a highly polished result on the new wave of machines, albeit with some oddities and blemishes that the developers should address. Bugs? Yes, they're there. I've seen AI and animation issues that break the immersion - mostly in the Operation Tonga mission. Enemies awkwardly repeat their animations in a group. You might catch a soldier, stood motionless in a battlefield without a gun - oblivious to the carnage around him. There are bizarre rag doll reactions on major characters. However, the most glaring issue I've seen so far comes down to performance. Xbox Series consoles see the campaign play out with some egregious - albeit sporadic - stutter, while PlayStation 5 sees checkpoint save pauses of around half-a-second. For a game that delivers so much polish and panache, it's a bit of a let-down. Beyond that, if we take ourselves away from the bugs for a moment, there's also a full screen motion blur effect enabled by default. It's overkill in its intensity, turning any quick camera pan into a smear. I turned it off right away, and I suspect for many it'll be more enjoyable switched off. Watch on YouTube Here's the Digital Foundry video breakdown of the Call of Duty: Vanguard campaign, tested on PS5 and Xbox Series consoles. I've also got to take issue with some bizarre presentation choices. The game runs at 60fps - as you'd expect for a Call of Duty titles - yet some elements shift to pre-rendered cinematics built on the game engine that run at 30fps instead (complete with macroblock artefacts). Typically, developers use pre-rendered scenes to push post-effects, big battles, huge environments, that the hardware can't deliver in real-time. But here, it's usually a continuation of what the consoles capably handle in-engine moments before. And then there's the end-of-chapter scenes. These are the real deal: beautifully directed, motion captured - almost movie-like in their visual quality, with heavy film grain layered on top. But curiously, they run at 24 frames per second. It's a "cinematic" 24fps - but yes, another jump in frame-rate from the 60fps of gameplay, and the 30fps in other scenes. It's all very strange. If we concentrate on core gameplay, factoring out the bugs, oddities and inconsistencies, we see something quite special. There's much in common with Modern Warfare 2019 and Warzone - a native 4K target in 60Hz mode, augmented with temporal super-sampling, and a dynamic resolution scaler that seems to run only on the horizontal axis. Series S? Impressively, this targets 1440p instead. Based on Rich Leadbetter's recent visit to Infinity Ward's tech hub in Poland (much more on this in due course) and prolonged eyeballing of debug screens on-site, PS5 - and by extension, Xbox Series X - usually runs at full resolution, with only very occasional resolution drops. This is in part achieved via an evolved system of variable rate shading (VRS), which IW8 handles via software, with a level of precision that exceeds AMD's hardware iteration. That's limited to dealing with 8x8 pixel blocks, while IW8 has much more precision. Part of the reason resolution is so consistently high is specifically because of this VRS system - why dynamically scale the whole X axis when more granular, less noticeable tweaking to resolution in specific areas of the screen can achieve similar effects? Series X and PlayStation 5 - stutters apart - are matched evenly, though there are some slight variations in the 120Hz mode support. All current-gen versions get this - even Xbox Series S - where target performance is doubled in exchange for a resolution drop, which seems to land at a peak of 1536p on Series X and PS5, and 1080p for Series S. Everything else seems to be a match for the 60Hz mode, the difference being that while 120fps is the target, there's not the same level of consistency. Xbox Series S Xbox Series X PlayStation 5A visual comparison between the PS5 and Series X and S releases shows the IW8 engine scaling well, with 4K targeted on the premium two machines, and 1440p on Series S. Draw distances are equal on all three as we move forward here. Xbox Series S Xbox Series X PlayStation 5Texture quality, materials and lighting are matched across the board - though curiously there's a small shadow bug that omits shade on PS5 and Series X on the right-side of this image. It's a one-off in our experience, and they're otherwise matched. Xbox Series S Xbox Series X PlayStation 5All support screen-space reflections across metallic surfaces, like in this hangar. Series S shows a small drop-off in clarity across reflected elements, but all are matched in every other sense.. Xbox Series S Xbox Series X PlayStation 5Lastly, an effects-heavy shot. Very little to split the trio once again, with fire alpha rendered at a likewise quality. Launch comparison tool Please enable JavaScript to use our comparison tools. In Short? There's no clear 'winner' here in Series X and PS5 performance - either can out-perform the other at any given point and often, there's little to split them at all - apart from the Microsoft consoles' screen-tearing, only located at the very top of the screen. The Microsoft advantage is at the system level - variable refresh rate support takes the minor stutter seen here and eliminates it entirely. Series S? This one struggles the most in attaining its 120Hz target. The opening Hamburg mission is a great workout, fluctuating between 60fps to 80fps - and it shows just how close Series S is to falling under 60fps in the regular mode. We're rarely touching the full 120Hz here, but all the same, I'm glad we at least have the option. I have played Vanguard in multiplayer mode, but for me, it's not a particularly compelling component of this year's entry. As short-lived as it may be, we do get a technologically impressive campaign this time, only set back by stuttering issues, bugs and polish. Performance is well optimised in most spots though, and while it can't always hit the target in its 120Hz mode, it's still well worth playing if you have the right display. Again, Vanguard shows how seamlessly the IW Engine scales across systems. Barely anything is lost, outside of the pixel count on Series S - where the visual direction of the holds up on all systems. As a milestone release for its engine and as a showcase of 60fps gaming and stunning scripted, set-piece moments, it's well worth playing through. Will you support the Digital Foundry team? Digital Foundry specialises in technical analysis of gaming hardware and software, using state-of-the-art capture systems and bespoke software to show you how well games and hardware run, visualising precisely what they're capable of. In order to show you what 4K gaming actually looks like we needed to build our own platform to supply high quality 4K video for offline viewing. So we did. Our videos are multi-gigabyte files and we've chosen a high quality provider to ensure fast downloads. However, that bandwidth isn't free and so we charge a small monthly subscription fee of £4.50. We think it's a small price to pay for unlimited access to top-tier quality encodes of our content. Thank you. Support Digital Foundry Find out more about the benefits of our Patreon More Face-offs Digital Foundry Nier Automata's Switch port is very impressive - but not quite perfect A game that struggled on PS4 and Xbox One transitions well to the Nintendo hybrid. 17 Digital Foundry Deathloop comes to Xbox Series X - and not much has changed from its PS5 debut But what about Series S? 74 Digital Foundry Intel's XeSS tested in depth vs DLSS - the Digital Foundry technology review A strong start for a new, more open AI upscaler. 6 Digital Foundry Soul Hackers 2: Atlus' new Persona-lite has major tech problems An intriguing game marred by primitive visuals and baffling performance. 18 Latest Articles Digital Foundry Nvidia GeForce RTX 4090: a new level in graphics performance The Digital Foundry video review - and how the new GPU champion delivers for 4K 120fps gaming. Feature Evercore Heroes wants to wind people up the right way "There's less rage at them, because they didn't end your fun." Google announces cloud gaming Chromebooks less than a fortnight after Stadia shutdown GeForce Now preinstalled. 4 Genshin Impact Path of Gleaming Jade dates, login event rewards Including other anniversary rewards and how to claim them. Supporters Only Premium only Off Topic: Take a minute to appreciate Cookin' with Coolio's incredible scallops recipe. What a great book. Premium only Off Topic: Reading City of Glass in comic form "Where exactly am I going?" Premium only Off Topic: Il Buco is a transporting film about a really big hole Underlands. Off-Topic Netflix handled Sandman brilliantly It was Dreamy. 9 Buy things with globes on them And other lovely Eurogamer merch in our official store! Explore our store