New Saliva Test Can Help Concussion Diagnosis Everyday Health MenuNewslettersSearch Concussion
A New Game-Changing Way to Improve Concussion Diagnosis
Research shows that a simple saliva test may hold the key to accurately diagnosing concussions in the future. By Stacey ColinoMedically Reviewed by Samuel Mackenzie, MD, PhDReviewed: December 2, 2020Medically ReviewedThe usual methods for diagnosing a concussion can be pretty subjective, but a new saliva test aims to change that.iStockConcussions are notoriously tricky to diagnose since doing so depends largely on a patient’s report of their symptoms. But all of that might change in the future. A new study in the journal of Clinical and Translational Medicine suggests that doctors may be able to more accurately diagnose concussions through a simple spit test, rather than relying on subjective reports (from a patient) or a clinical judgment call (by a physician). The test would take a sample of saliva and measure levels of certain forms of micro-ribonucleic acid (microRNA), which is a small strand of genetic material that is naturally present in the brain. In the study, researchers from Penn State University College of Medicine in Hershey, Pennsylvania, compared saliva samples from 251 people with a mild traumatic brain injury (aka a concussion) with those from 287 control subjects without head injuries. They found that differences in specific microRNA levels distinguished those with concussions from those without. In some cases, participants were assessed with computerized neurocognitive testing, balance measures, and standardized symptom scales, and the saliva tests displayed similar accuracy in identifying concussions as a combination of the traditional approaches. “Even though saliva RNA accuracy is comparable to traditional approaches, it might have added utility when there is suspicion an athlete is minimizing symptoms after their head injury to expedite return to play, when an athlete may have purposely underperformed a baseline balance/neurocognitive test to avoid being held out after a suspected concussion, or in busy emergency department or outpatient settings where doctors don't have 30 minutes to administer balance/neurocognitive tests,” explains Steven Hicks, MD, PhD, an associate professor of pediatrics at Penn State College of Medicine. “Patients can't alter their saliva RNA content, and it takes only seconds for a physician to collect a saliva sample.” What Saliva Reveals
Why can testing saliva detect concussions? Throughout the body, “cells use microRNAs to communicate with each other — this includes [cells in the] nerves in the mouth that connect directly with your brain stem and control things like chewing, speaking, and sensation,” explains Dr. Hicks. “We believe that the microRNA signals from these nerves are disrupted after a concussion — some go up and some go down — and measuring the levels of various microRNAs gives us insight into the severity of the injury.” Though he was not involved in the study, Andrew Gregory, MD, an associate professor of orthopedics, pediatrics, and neurosurgery at Vanderbilt University Medical Center in Nashville, Tennessee, sees the value in this approach. “It is an objective measure,” he explains. “MicroRNA can be measured in various body fluids, but saliva is easiest to access.” A New Addition to the Diagnostic Arsenal
This is a potential game changer since the usual methods for diagnosing a concussion are so subjective. They typically depend on the symptoms reported by the patient and a neurocognitive examination of the patient’s reflexes, strength, vision, balance, memory, and cognitive functioning. Hicks hopes that the saliva test, rather than being a stand-alone tool for concussion diagnosis, will become “an additional tool available to clinicians that allows them to detect concussion with greater accuracy.” This is especially important because symptoms of concussions can vary widely, ranging from headache, blurry vision, confusion, and difficulty concentrating to nausea, dizziness, and sensitivity to noise or light. Some people are forthcoming about their symptoms while others may be less so. Indeed, sometimes people “minimize their symptoms to expedite returning to activities,” Hicks says. “Even semi-objective tools like balance or reaction time testing can be tricked by patients who purposely sandbag their baseline test.” Following a head trauma, “analyzing microRNA profiles in saliva is a noninvasive way to test for concussion that can’t be influenced by a patient’s feelings or motives,” he adds. Pluses and Minuses of the Spit Test
Even though saliva RNA can be rapidly collected and objectively measured, the saliva test isn’t 100 percent accurate in detecting concussions. “When used by itself, the RNA test was 85.7 percent accurate; when used together with a validated symptom survey, the RNA test was 93.2 percent accurate,” Hicks notes. (By contrast, diagnosing concussions by surveying symptoms and performing neurocognitive testing is 88.8 accurate, Hicks notes.) “I think it could be potentially useful for diagnosis in cases with minimal or unclear symptoms or with an athlete suspected to be lying,” Dr. Gregory says. It could also be useful in making decisions about whether it’s safe for someone to return to playing a sport after suffering a concussion. Before the saliva RNA test can be brought into widespread use, however, larger studies need to be conducted to confirm its efficacy. That said, a handheld tool is already being developed to measure microRNA samples from saliva in less than 30 minutes, Hicks says. “We are hopeful this technology could be clinically available within three years.” NEWSLETTERS Sign up for our Healthy Living Newsletter
SubscribeBy subscribing you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. The Latest in Concussion
Does My Child Have a Concussion
Bumps and bruises are normal for physically active kids who explore the world head-on. But concussions are not. Here’s what you need to know about the...By Michelle SeitzerAugust 19, 2022 Everything You Need to Know About Concussions in Sports
Get the facts about how common concussions are in sports, as well as how to keep yourself — or your children — safe from a brain injury during recreational...By Ashley WelchMarch 31, 2022 What Are the Symptoms of a Concussion
Here’s what you need to look out for if you suspect you’ve had a mild traumatic brain injury, so that you can get it diagnosed and treated.By Lisa RapaportMarch 24, 2022 What Complications Can Arise From a Concussion
While most symptoms of a concussion will resolve within a few weeks, some people can experience complications that last much longer.By Ashley WelchMarch 16, 2022 How Concussions Affect Males and Females Differently
What you should know about the gender differences in traumatic brain injuries.By Ashley WelchMarch 15, 2022 How Is a Concussion Treated and What Can You Do During the Recovery Period
There is no specific treatment for a concussion, but several things can help reduce the severity and length of symptoms.By Ashley WelchMarch 10, 2022 What Is a Concussion Symptoms Causes Diagnosis and Treatment
By Ashley WelchMarch 7, 2022 Type of Headache Matters in Concussion Recovery Study Finds
Kids who have post-concussion migraine headaches may take longer to recover.By Kaitlin SullivanMarch 12, 2021 Football Concussions Occur Mostly in Practice Not Games
Experts urge education and reform to football practice rules.By Jordan M. DavidsonFebruary 22, 2021 Melatonin Tied to Better Brain Function in Kids With Concussions
Children recovering from concussions who take melatonin may have improved function in regions of the brain thought to regulate sleep, a small experiment...By Lisa RapaportOctober 26, 2020 MORE IN How Dementia Is Diagnosed
Cystic Fibrosis Symptoms and Diagnosis
Symptoms and Diagnosis of Hemophilia A