Paolo Zamboni Admits He Was Wrong About CCSVI and MS Everyday Health MenuNewslettersSearch Multiple Sclerosis News
Scientist Who Named CCSVI the Cause of MS Admits He Was Wrong
Dr. Paolo Zamboni has publicly concluded that “the liberation treatment” for MS does not work. By Trevis GleasonFor Life With Multiple SclerosisDecember 1, 2017Everyday Health BlogsFact-CheckedPaolo Zamboni at a National Multiple Sclerosis Society event.Nathan Denette/AP PhotoAlmost a decade ago the multiple sclerosis (MS) world was rocked, tossed, and turned on its ear when a Canadian television program aired astonishing footage of people being “cured” of MS. The program followed Italian vascular surgeon Paolo Zamboni as he expanded the neck veins of individuals with MS (sometimes stenting the veins to keep them open), and declared these people free of MS symptoms. He claimed that a condition he called CCSVI, which stands for chronic cerebrospinal venous insufficiency, was the cause of multiple sclerosis, and that the angioplasty procedure he was performing was the treatment. I was a hopeful skeptic of the procedure from the start. That skepticism earned me not a few vocal detractors over the years, but I could never get my head around the science of the thing. No matter what angle I looked at the idea from, it just didn’t make sense. Zamboni s Own Research Fails to Show Efficacy
The final nail may have placed into the CCSVI-liberation treatment coffin last week, and it was placed there by Dr. Zamboni himself, when a clinical trial in which he participated, published online in November 2017 in Jama Neurology, concluded that venous angioplasty, as prescribed by Zamboni, was a largely ineffective technique and cannot be recommended to patients with MS. The study included 115 people with relapsing-remitting MS, 76 of whom received the real treatment and 39 of whom received a sham treatment. While none of the study participants experienced adverse effects, the treatment was not shown to be effective at improving patients’ physical functioning or reducing the number of new lesions seen on MRI (magnetic resonance imaging) 12 months after the procedure. It is a sad day for the thousands of people who depleted their savings, borrowed and raised funds, and traveled to clinics internationally seeking liberation treatment. It’s particularly sad for those who suffered complications and sometimes irreversible damage from the treatment. And some people may have even died as a result of having it. Social Media Fueled Interest in Unproven Therapy
I believe that sociologists and medical ethicists will study the CCSVI controversy for decades to come. It came at a unique time when “old” media and social media traded places with regards to where people were getting their news. It came at a time — the first time — when what a relatively few people saw on television one night in Canada was transmitted to and by excited MS patients around the world. Science does not move at the speed of modern social media, and that will be difficult for many to accept for a good long time, I’d suspect. While there will always be those who believe the treatment worked for them and that it was “the system” that put down the methodology, in the end, it was good science prevailing over bad. Time to Look Elsewhere for an MS Cure
I thought I’d written my final blog about CCSVI a number of years ago when a preponderance of evidence was building against the theory. Now that the founder of the theory has taken to persuading people with MS not to pursue liberation therapy, I believe this will be my final word on the topic. Now, on to the next step in our journey to a cure. Wishing you and your family the best of health. Cheers, Trevis My book, Chef Interrupted, is available on Amazon. Follow me on the Life With MS Facebook page and on Twitter, and subscribe to Life With Multiple Sclerosis. Important: The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and not Everyday Health.See More NEWSLETTERS Sign up for our Multiple Sclerosis Newsletter
SubscribeBy subscribing you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. The Latest in Multiple Sclerosis
How to Craft a Life s Mission Statement
By Trevis GleasonOctober 21, 2022 Dysarthria When MS Makes It Hard to Speak
By Mona SenOctober 20, 2022 Is That Really How I Walk
By Trevis GleasonOctober 18, 2022 How Do You Know When to Throw in the Towel
By Trevis GleasonOctober 14, 2022 Living With MS What to Know About Neuropathic Pain and How to Manage It
Neuropathic pain is not your average pain. Here’s what to know about this unique type of MS pain and how to find relief.By Kerry WeissOctober 12, 2022 UTIs and MS The Importance of Early Diagnosis and Treatment
If you have multiple sclerosis, you may be prone to frequent urinary tract infections. Besides being painful, UTIs can make MS worse, so it’s important...By Kerry WeissOctober 12, 2022 Why Is Orange the Color of MS
By Trevis GleasonOctober 11, 2022 13 Celebrities Who Have Multiple Sclerosis
Look among the millions of people with multiple sclerosis and you'll find famous faces, too. Learn how some of these celebrities are dealing with MS and...By Regina Boyle WheelerOctober 11, 2022 We All Have Something to Teach Our MS Doctors
By Trevis GleasonOctober 7, 2022 EBV An MS Box I Can Finally Tick
By Trevis GleasonOctober 4, 2022 More In Life With Multiple Sclerosis How to Craft a Life s Mission Statement
Is That Really How I Walk
How Do You Know When to Throw in the Towel